In Shakespeare's play, Much Ado About Nothing, written in the early 15th century, the relationships between Benedick and Beatrice and Hero and Claudio are. Free Essay: Explore and compare the romantic relationships in the play; Beatrice and Benedick, Claudio and Hero The theme of love is the fundamental premise. Much Ado About Nothing Essays - Much Ado About Nothing Essay: Beatrice, ( ) and an opponent to marriage, he tells Claudio that Beatrice 'an she.
The comedy is well known for its tragedies, deception, mischief and love stories. In this piece of coursework I will be examining and comparing the relationship between 'Beatrice and Benedick' and the relationship between 'Hero and Claudio', the two central couples in Shakespeare's play.
During the period when Shakespeare wrote 'Much Ado About Nothing', love and marriage was looked upon in a different way as it is today. One theme that was clear throughout many of his pieces is the theme of love; whether it be obvious or underlying, romantic or lustful. The notion of romantic love is often explored in his sonnets; a typical sonnet is 14 lines in length with a strict rhyme-scheme and also iambic pentameter, it could be suggested that the strict sonnet form is an analogy for unwavering and timeless, true love.
From the very first scene of Much Ado About Nothing it is obvious that Beatrice and Benedick will eventually fall in love Essay Essay 33 Words 6 Pages I agree it is obvious from the very first scene that Beatrice and Benedick will fall in love. This is because of many important signs throughout the first scene of this play, which give the impression that Beatrice and Benedick will fall in love. One reason why I agree with this statement is that Beatrice and Benedick both come from rich families and people tend to marry into the same social class.
Beatrice and Benedick are from rich families as they're friends with Don Pedro and Leonato, who are aristocrats. Benedick is a soldier, but obviously in a high rank Much Ado About Nothing is a romantic comedy. Without detracting from the obvious frivolity that the audience can see on stage, the play invokes many issues about courtship and marriage and Shakespeare deals with them, Shakespeare uses love and relationships to closely examine and comment on how relationships developed in the society he lived in.
She cannot love, nor take no shape nor project of affection, she is so self-endeared. Sure, I think so. What fire is in mine ears? Can this be true? Stand I condemned for pride and scorn so much? Contempt, farewell; and maiden pride, adieu; No glory lives behind the back of such.
And Benedick, love on, I will requite thee, Taming my wild heart to thy loving hand. III, i, As already stated above, these very quick and extreme reactions to the intrigues played to Beatrice and Benedick can be explained by the fact that in their relationship it is not their affection for each other that is vulnerable to outside influences as it is the case with Hero and Claudio but their bad wits. Since — as has been shown further above using the beginning of the play — Beatrice and Benedick have everything that real love is based on interest in and affection towards each other, similar characteristics, and a shared wish for true lovetheir environment does not have the ability to destroy it.
Example research essay topic Hero And Claudio Beatrice And Benedick
In contrast, their pride and bad wit, which have served as shields for their true feelings for each other, are vulnerable to outside influences.
In other words, the plot hatched by their friends forces them to realise for the first time that they indeed feel attracted to one another. Therefore, the effect of the eavesdropping scenes supports the claim that Beatrice and Benedick represent true love in Much Ado about Nothing. The fact that Beatrice and Benedick further develop their affection that was created through the tricks played to the characters in acts 2 and 3 into actual love through a proof of loyalty supports the claim that they represent real love in Much Ado about Nothing.
This can be seen very well in the soliloquies of the two characters directly after they are tricked. Beatrice, for instance, remarks: Contempt, farewell; and maiden pride adieu; No glory lives behind the back of such. And Benedick, love on, I will requite thee, taming my wild heart to thy loving hand. Thus, it is a result of reasonable thought rather than an abundance of passion for Benedick.
II, iii, Here also, one can see that the decision to marry Beatrice is not primarily based on mad passion for her but that it goes hand in hand with him realising that his environment finds him proud. However, in all this it must not be forgotten that the two indeed do feel affection for each other — as has been shown earlier in the analysis. As in the case with Claudio's attraction to Hero, it is 1 often based only on outer appearance.
Lacking actual knowledge of the other, the infatuated one usually projects his or her own desires and longings on the beloved.
However, this stage of their relationship — which can be seen as a step backwards on the way to real love — ends when Beatrice demands Benedick to kill his friend Claudio because the latter has denunciated Hero at the first wedding scene in the play. As has been shown in the analysis of the beginning of the play above, the couple serves as critics of the traditional way of living and loving of their time.
This can, for instance, be seen on the many occasions when Benedick speaks of cuckolded husbands e. On the one hand, she wants Benedick to convince her that he is worth trusting in. This can be seen very well in the dialogue between the couple after the condemnation of Hero has happened: Come, bid me do anything for thee.
Ha, not for the wide world. You kill me to deny it. I am gone, though I am here. There is no love in you; nay, I pray you, let me go. Through this test of loyalty, it has thus been proven to both Beatrice and Benedick that they can trust each other. Thus, what kept them from letting themselves fall into true love with each other beforehand — namely the firm belief that the other sex is disloyal — has now gone. Quite clearly, Shakespeare hints at this fate near the close of the play: Do not you love me?
Why no, no more than reason. Why then your uncle and the prince and Claudio have been deceived — they swore you did.
- How to cite this page
- Found what you're looking for?
- Learn more
Troth no, no more than reason. Why then my cousin, Margaret and Ursula are much deceived, for they swear you did. They swore that you were almost sick for me. They swore that you were well-nigh dead for me. Then you do not love me?
After studying the relationship between Hero and Claudio, I have established the similarities the couple share. Firstly, I come to the conclusion that both Hero and Claudio are not confident people. Claudio does not have the confidence to talk to Hero and approach himself. Therefore, Don Pedro does the talking for Claudio. Hero displays her un confident manor in a different way. She is conventional in the relationship between herself and Claudio and acts like what people expect of her.
She displays the tradition Courtly love throughout the relationship and displays all the actions a typical Elizabethan women was expected to do.
Secondly, Hero and Claudio base their feelings for each other mainly on the looks of one another. Both want to marry at the start of the play also. Lastly, Hero and Claudio act more immaturely, apposed to Beatrice and Benedick. I cannot state any clear differences between the couple. When comparing the relationship between both couples there are similarities and differences.
The main similarity and only similarity I can think of between both couples is the trickery used, resulting in both couple getting married. Beatrice and Benedick were tricked into confessing their love for one another and Claudio was tricked into thinking many things, although Claudio still ends up marrying Hero. There are many differences between both couples.
Hero and Claudio's relationship is based solely on the sexual love they have for on another. They are mainly in love with each others looks, making the relationship very shallow. On the other hand Beatrice and Benedick's relationship is much deeper, based on not only looks but also personality. Beatrice and Benedick's relationship took a longer time to blossom and the couple knew each other for a longer time apposed to Hero and Claudio's relationship, which only starts to take place at the masked ball.
The final difference is that Benedick and Beatrice took time to finally confess their feelings for one another, whereas Hero and Claudio announced their feelings for each other straight away.
The relationship Benedick and Beatrice Essay
Overall, I think both relationships will last but to different factors. I think Hero and Claudio's relationship will last but only on the fact that they have feelings for one another based on looks. I think Beatrice and Benedick's relationship will be the happiest as they have more solid foundations.
They both have a lot in common; their views, intellect and history.
I think the most secure relationship will be Beatrice's and Benedick's. I think this as their relationship is based on more than just looks. The feelings for one another seem genuine and when analysing the couple it seems to me that they are a match made in Heaven.
Overall I think Much Ado About Nothing is a magical and superb play showing Shakespeare's gift for writing throughout. I enjoyed reading the play, as it did not fail to surprise me with its twists.
I think it tells the history of Elizabethan marriage superbly. I enjoyed reading the battles of wit that took place between Beatrice and Benedick mostly. If I had the chance to see Much Ado About Nothing in theatre I would as I think it would turn out to be a very entertaining and enjoyable play. Shakespeare's work did not appeal to me before reading the play Much Ado About Nothing, but now after reading it I will have to re-evaluate my thoughts as if each play is as superb as this one, I will be reading a lot more of Shakespeare's works.